Don't undercut the high-producing cows
Camila Lage, Dairy Management Specialist
Southwest New York Dairy, Livestock and Field Crops Program
Don't undercut the high-producing cows
BY ABBY BAUER, SENIOR ASSOCIATE EDITOR (For the original article click here)
With input costs on the rise, farmers across the country are looking for ways to improve profitability and reduce spending. Feed is a big cost center and one that often gets scrutinized, but during the November Hoard's Dairyman webinar, Mike Hutjens advised the audience that the ration is not the place to cut corners.
"Cutting back on milk production is bad news," said Hutjens, a professor emeritus at the University of Illinois. That's because we only get to set peak milk once in a lactation, he explained, and if a cow's production is hindered, that is the lactation curve we are "stuck with" for the next 300 days.
Hutjens shared that 1 pound of dry matter costs about 16 cents right now, while 1 pound of milk is worth about 24 cents. One pound of extra dry matter intake supports 2 or more pounds of milk production. The value of those 2 pounds of milk is 48 cents, minus 16 cents for the pound of dry matter it takes to produce those 2 pounds, leading to a profit of 32 cents per cow per day for each pound of dry matter consumed.
"That is profit," Hutjens said. "I am not going to underfeed my herd of cows."
He also pointed to some feed benchmarks from Illinois for the upcoming year in the table below. At a feed cost of 16 cents per pound of dry matter, it costs $8.16 per cow per day. The difference in the return on the feed investment between cows milking 80 pounds per day and those milking 70 pounds per day is quite stark.

It costs less money per 100 pounds of milk to feed cows that are milking more, and the income over feed costs goes up almost $1.50 for cows producing 80 pounds compared to those milking 70 pounds. Feed efficiency climbs from 1.43 pounds of milk per pound of dry matter to 1.63 pounds when milk production is at 80 pounds per day. These numbers further support Hutjens' advice to not undercut a cow's milk potential.
"High producing cows are most efficient and most profitable," Hutjens emphasized. "Don't restrict or penalize good cows."
Upcoming Events
Driving Efficiency in Dairy & Exploring the Irish Experience
September 29, 2025
Rock Stream, NY
This workshop series will feature in-depth presentation and discussion led by Dr. Padraig French who is the Head of Livestock Systems and the Dairy Enterprise Leader at Teagasc (the Irish version of USDA). Dr. French will focus on the critical success factors for Irish dairy, which include pasture utilization, labor efficiency and managing for seasonal calving. The discussion will focus on ways that U.S. dairy farmers can use some of the Irish dairy techniques to become more profitable with grass farming.
Open Forum to Discuss Newly Approved DOL Trade, "Butcher"
October 2, 2025 : Open Forum to Discuss Newly Approved DOL Trade, "Butcher"
Partners from New York State Dept. of Labor, Cornell Cooperative Extension, Southern Tier West, and Workforce Development will be in the space to provide an overview of the new program, discuss the roles of hosts and apprentices, review the benefits of hosting an apprentice, and setting the vision for building a corps of highly skilled, modern trained Butchers and validating this career as a skilled trade with respectful earning potential.
Silvopasture on a Shoestring
October 7, 2025
Franklinville, NY
Join Joshua Greene, Director of Education at Trees For Graziers, Jonathan Bates, Statewide Agroforestry Educator, and Lynn Bliven, owner of Wild Geese Farm for a full day training event that will include classroom and hands-on sessions. The focus will be on DIY silvopasture projects on small grazing farms. We will address the practical considerations of tree establishment, protection, and maintenance while learning how silvopasture can help address your farm's resource concerns and enhance livestock grazing.
Announcements
No announcements at this time.