A Review of the Endangered Species Act and Pesticides: An Example

Katelyn Miller, Field Crops and Forage Specialist
Southwest New York Dairy, Livestock and Field Crops Program

April 29, 2024
A Review of the Endangered Species Act and Pesticides: An Example

The Endangered Species Act (ESA) passed in 1973 requires government agencies to ensure actions taken will not threaten any species that have been federally listed as endangered or threatened. Whenever an agency has a proposed action that might affect an endangered species or its habitat, they are required to consult with one of two agencies. These agencies are the U.S Fish and Wildlife Service and U.S. National Marine Fisheries Service. These agencies, commonly referred to as the "Services" provide a biological opinion which determines if the proposed action would cause jeopardy or adverse effects to any species or habitat. If they identify a risk, the action needs to be modified to avoid harm. This is also referred to as a consultation.

The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) oversees all pesticide use. The use of pesticides is considered an action which would require an endangered species consultation. Because the EPA has not complied with the ESA, the Federal Court has ordered them to conduct consultations on all current and newly registered pesticides. Currently, there are over 1,100 active ingredients that need to go through this review process, not including new active ingredients entering the market. To speed up the process, the EPA is developing strategies for the different groups of pesticides. Here's the current timeline:

  • This past year, the EPA had an open comment period on their herbicide strategy. The final version should be available in August of 2024.
  • The final version of the rodenticide strategy is planned to be released in November 2024.
  • The insecticide strategy is scheduled for release in 2025. Currently, neonicotinoids are under review.
  • The fungicide strategy is scheduled to be released in 2026.
  • There is no schedule set for biopesticides at this time.

After these strategies are finalized, it will still take years before all pesticides have been evaluated for ESA impacts and the labels change as a result. It's important to check the label every time you purchase a product as these changes can be implemented on a label at any point. This change impacts growers where listed threatened and endangered species and agriculture overlap. There will be changes in labeling that may require additional management practices to be implemented. Some of these changes could include:

  • Label requirement to check Bulletins Live! Two for additional labeling information. You can access the website here: https://www.epa.gov/endangered-species/bulletins-live-two-view-bulletins. If any additional labeling is released about a pesticide, it can be found here.
  • Restrictions may be in place on application to saturated soils.
  • Mitigation strategies to reduce spray drift and runoff/erosion. If products are identified as having a high risk to impact threated and endangered species, mitigation strategies may need to be implemented to use certain products using a point system. Some examples include but are not limited to removing states or counties of concern, reducing application rates, the total number of applications and field buffers.  

It's important to make sure that you are always reading the label on your pesticide labels no matter how frequently you purchase a product. If you're interested, the recording of this webinar is available on YouTube on the NYSIPM channel, which can be found here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WeuakbASnRU

The following information is summarized from the webinar hosted by the Weed Science Society of America titled "Endangered Species Act and Pesticides: An Example". Every effort has been made to provide correct, complete, and up to date pesticide recommendations. Changes occur constantly and human errors are still possible. These recommendations are not a substitute for pesticide labeling. Please read the label before applying pesticides.




Field Crops

Field Crops

Dairy

Dairy

Business

Business

Livestock

Livestock

Grains

Grains

Upcoming Events

WNY Pastureland Conversion & Soil Health Field Day

July 16, 2025
Middleport, NY

Join American Farmland Trust for the Western New York Soil Health Field Day on July 16, 2025, at Zeliff Farm in Middleport, NY, from 9:00 AM-3:15 PM. Learn about pasture conversion, soil health benchmarking, biochar in grazing systems, and best grazing practices. Plus, enjoy hands-on demos with the NY Soil Health Trailer, drones, and cover crops!  Check out the attached agenda for more information about the field day and REGISTER HERE. Zeliff Farms is a regenerative beef operation who has recently partnered with AFT on outreach and education to farmers including learning circles and evaluating biochar effects on soil health.

View WNY Pastureland Conversion & Soil Health Field Day Details

IPM Strategies to Protect Corn and Soybean Seed in NY

Event Offers DEC Credits

July 30, 2025
Hamburg , NY

SWNYDLFC and Cornell IPM are hosting a grower meeting to discuss integrated pest management strategies for protecting corn and soybean seed in New York. 

View IPM Strategies to Protect Corn and Soybean Seed in NY Details

FAMACHA Training for Sheep and Goat producers in Woodhull NY

August 13, 2025 : FAMACHA Training in Woodhull
Woodhull, NY

Join us for a discussion and hands-on training for internal parasite integrated pest management in sheep and goats. Certification is available to all students participating in the workshop.

View FAMACHA Training for Sheep and Goat producers in Woodhull NY Details

Announcements

No announcements at this time.

NEWSLETTER   |   CURRENT PROJECTS   |   IMPACT IN NY   |   SPONSORSHIP  |  RESOURCES   |   SITE MAP