Could farmers be teaching cows bad habits? by Carla Wardin

Could farmers be teaching cows bad habits?
BY CARLA WARDIN, MICHIGAN DAIRY FARMER
Although it might be entertaining to see cows running toward the feedbunk and eagerly start eating, this is also a sign that they're hungry. Unfortunately, they might be so hungry that it's a detriment.
"The reason why that can be concerning is that if cows do that too much, they're going to consume too much feed too quickly," said Trevor DeVries, professor and cattle behavior specialist at the University of Guelph. "That can then have a negative impact on the rumen environment."
"Those large meals get digested fairly quickly, particularly the highly fermentable carbohydrates," he continued during "Troubleshooting Herd Health Issues on Your Dairy-Feeding Behavior," a Cornell Cooperative Extension podcast. "As a result of that, rumen pH gets potentially depressed, and with that, fiber digestibility gets depressed. Those things can then have a negative impact on passage rate from the rumen, overall digestibility, and even influence the risk of milkfat depression, so that's potentially problematic."
Factors to consider when troubleshooting feeding behavior include:
- The size differentiation of cattle
- Group dynamics
- Stocking density
- Time needed to devote to the feedbunk - not waiting to be milked
- Small meals that encourage consistent eating patterns
- Early life management
- Continual access to feed
- Minimizing social stress and competition
Stop the sorting
Management plays a role in feedbunk behavior, as farmers don't have to just think about what feed animals consume, but also the manner in which they eat it. For instance, it's important that the total mixed ration (TMR) is well-combined so they can't completely sort it.
"Cows are pretty adept at picking through what they like," DeVries said.
He cited data from studies that showed that when calves are weaned and fed grain and hay separately, farmers don't always get the results they want.
"What we've found in some of that work is that when we feed calves that way, they tend to go to the feed bunk and consume all their grain fairly quickly, particularly if there's any competition at the feedbunk, and then pick at the forage for the remainder of the day," he said.
In their studies, they compared animal behavior in calves getting a mixed TMR and a nonmixed variation.
"We found that those calves that were fed their dietary components separately not only exhibited that slug feeding-type response when they go to the bunk and eat grain really quickly, but those animals actually became more competitive at the feedbunk," said DeVries. "Then when we switched those animals after a period of time onto a common diet, we observed that those animals actually retained those same eating behavior patterns," he said.
Humans change cattle behavior
As a result, management caused this change in animal behavior.
"So, we actually induced the learning of that slug feeding just based on how we fed those animals. Definitely, there is opportunity managing feeding early on in life to have a potential impact on the development of the carryover of these meal patterns and meal behavior patterns," he said.
Upcoming Events
WNY Pastureland Conversion & Soil Health Field Day
July 16, 2025
Middleport, NY
Join American Farmland Trust for the Western New York Soil Health Field Day on July 16, 2025, at Zeliff Farm in Middleport, NY, from 9:00 AM-3:15 PM. Learn about pasture conversion, soil health benchmarking, biochar in grazing systems, and best grazing practices. Plus, enjoy hands-on demos with the NY Soil Health Trailer, drones, and cover crops! Check out the attached agenda for more information about the field day and REGISTER HERE. Zeliff Farms is a regenerative beef operation who has recently partnered with AFT on outreach and education to farmers including learning circles and evaluating biochar effects on soil health.
IPM Strategies to Protect Corn and Soybean Seed in NY

July 30, 2025
Hamburg , NY
SWNYDLFC and Cornell IPM are hosting a grower meeting to discuss integrated pest management strategies for protecting corn and soybean seed in New York.
FAMACHA Training for Sheep and Goat producers in Woodhull NY
August 13, 2025 : FAMACHA Training in Woodhull
Woodhull, NY
Join us for a discussion and hands-on training for internal parasite integrated pest management in sheep and goats. Certification is available to all students participating in the workshop.
Announcements
No announcements at this time.