Negotiating Land Leases & Building Strong Relationships for Long-Term Success
Katelyn Walley, Business Management Specialist and Team Leader
Southwest New York Dairy, Livestock and Field Crops Program
Leasing farmland can be a great opportunity for both farmers and landowners, but it takes good communication and a fair agreement to make it work. In small towns and rural communities, word gets around fast—so it's important to start off on the right foot and keep things positive. Here are some key steps to help you negotiate a land lease that benefits everyone.
Before Negotiating: Do Your Homework
Good communication is key from the start. Before reaching out to a landowner, take time to explain your farming practices and what you'll need from the lease. A little old-fashioned kindness, like bringing cookies or a friendly conversation, can go a long way in making a good first impression.
It's also important to know your numbers. Understand your break-even price, check local rental rates, and be ready to explain why your offer is fair. If you're looking for new land, use resources like tax parcel records, word of mouth, or even town offices to find potential leases.
During Negotiations: Be Honest and Flexible
When discussing rental prices, keep things realistic. Some landowners may try to negotiate like they're at a flea market, but it's best to focus on fair market value. If cash rent is too high, consider offering barter services—such as snow plowing, providing meat, or making infrastructure improvements—in exchange for a lower rental price.
Be upfront about your farm's budget and expected expenses. Transparency helps build trust and prevents misunderstandings down the road. And if things get complicated, don't hesitate to bring in legal counsel to make sure both sides are protected.
After the Lease is Signed: Keep the Conversation Going
A good lease agreement doesn't mean communication stops. Set up times to check in, especially before planting season and when it's time to renew the lease. If you plan to spray pesticides, spread manure, or work late in the field, give the landowner a heads-up. Likewise, landowners should inform you if they plan to host special events or use the land for recreation.
At the end of the day, being a good neighbor makes a big difference. Clear communication and mutual respect help avoid conflicts and keep things running smoothly—so you can focus on farming without unnecessary stress.
Most Importantly: Get it in Writing!
Having a written and signed lease agreement is the most important thing you can do to protect yourself and set yourself up for success. No matter how good a handshake deal may seem, always get your lease in writing. A written lease protects both you and the landowner by clearly outlining rent, lease length, responsibilities, and any special agreements (such as bartering services). Verbal agreements can lead to misunderstandings down the road, so having everything documented helps prevent disputes and makes renewal discussions easier.
Upcoming Events
Optimizing the Economic Return of Pasture-Raised Slow-Growth and Conventional Broilers - Webinar
November 13, 2025 : Optimizing the Economic Return of Pasture-Raised Slow-Growth and Conventional Broilers - Webinar
Over the past three years, Cornell Cooperative Extension has worked with nearly 40 small farmers across NYS to gather information on the true costs of raising broilers (meat chickens) on pasture. This presentation is a summary of the findings of this research project.
NY Small Farms Summit 2025: Stronger Together
December 5, 2025
Alfred, NY
We hope you will join us on December 5th for the 2025 New York Small Farms Summit! This is an opportunity to meet other farmers and ag supporters, learn about research and education projects, and set priorities for future efforts to grow small farm success.
At the Allegany County site, we will focus on giving trees a chance and how trees build resiliency on small farms. Whether attracted to fruit, nuts, vegetables, fodder or shade, trees can be an integral part of a successful farming system. Join us as we explore the opportunities for resiliency that come from adding tree crops or managing wooded areas of your farm for agroforestry or silvopasture systems.
Crops, Cows & Critters - Southwest New York Dairy, Livestock & Field Crops Newsletter Sponsorship
December 19, 2025
Our two forms of publications feature research-based and timely information from our four specialists, listed to the right, along with local event notifications and Cornell University outreach. This information is provided to participants who range from dairy, livestock, and field crops producers to agricultural suppliers and consultants.
Weekly Email Update: Shared with 625+ households who have signed up with our program.
Monthly Paper Mailer: To reach our stakeholders and farmers who lack internet access, we send out a monthly mailer where your company's logo and contact information would be featured with a mailing list of 330+ households.
If you sponsor our weekly and monthly publications you reach approximately 955 households.
Visit our website to view our newsletters!
Announcements
No announcements at this time.





